I see three sources on the focal event — the announcement of the "Refuge" — but admittedly I have qualms about their degree of mutual independence. They seem to be pretty much the same article in three different languages. There are some mitigating factors. The French version appears to have some additional info in it. The French version refers to an earlier article about an announcement of pretty much the same thing on May 7, which I really wondered about, but as far as corroboration goes it's a plus. It's clear they did make some sort of announcement on Friday, and I decided therefore to allow the characterization of the announcement, and not object regarding the relevance of an announcement whose degree of originality is hidden behind a language barrier (I know something about these languages, but on the standard wikimedian scale I'd rate pretty much zero on all of them but English). The peripheral coverage of the parade itself helps just a bit to shore up the article's newsworthiness.
The question of ten flats, versus places for ten people, was not clearly resolved by the cited sources; they all used the word "place" or its cognate in the respective languages, but there's a lot of room for ambiguity there. However, the May 7 announcement source, linked from the French source, clearly stated the intent was to have two apartments accommodating up to a total of ten people.
I did wonder about the list of politicians, which in the source included their political parties but here only provided the names, which mostly won't mean much to international readers.
The reviewed revision should automatically have been edited by removing {{Review}} and adding {{Publish}} at the bottom, and the edit sighted; if this did not happen, it may be done manually by a reviewer.
I see three sources on the focal event — the announcement of the "Refuge" — but admittedly I have qualms about their degree of mutual independence. They seem to be pretty much the same article in three different languages. There are some mitigating factors. The French version appears to have some additional info in it. The French version refers to an earlier article about an announcement of pretty much the same thing on May 7, which I really wondered about, but as far as corroboration goes it's a plus. It's clear they did make some sort of announcement on Friday, and I decided therefore to allow the characterization of the announcement, and not object regarding the relevance of an announcement whose degree of originality is hidden behind a language barrier (I know something about these languages, but on the standard wikimedian scale I'd rate pretty much zero on all of them but English). The peripheral coverage of the parade itself helps just a bit to shore up the article's newsworthiness.
The question of ten flats, versus places for ten people, was not clearly resolved by the cited sources; they all used the word "place" or its cognate in the respective languages, but there's a lot of room for ambiguity there. However, the May 7 announcement source, linked from the French source, clearly stated the intent was to have two apartments accommodating up to a total of ten people.
I did wonder about the list of politicians, which in the source included their political parties but here only provided the names, which mostly won't mean much to international readers.
The reviewed revision should automatically have been edited by removing {{Review}} and adding {{Publish}} at the bottom, and the edit sighted; if this did not happen, it may be done manually by a reviewer.
Mentioning or not mentioning political parties might have little to no effect for the "international" audience -- when I was reading the source, knowing the names of the political party really didn't help -- but I used it more like a helper info to set up information for ex-PM's presence. •–•23:39, 21 May 2018 (UTC)Reply
