| Results - April 16, 2005 (edit) | ||||
| American League | ||||
| MIN | 6 | CLE | 4 | F |
| SEA | 1 | CWS | 2 | F |
| DET | 7 | KC | 1 | F |
| LAA | 0 | OAK | 1 | F (10) |
| NYY | 6 | BAL | 7 | F |
| TB | 2 | BOS | 6 | F |
| TOR | 8 | TEX | 0 | F |
| National League | ||||
| FLA | 3 | NYM | 4 | F |
| HOU | 2 | CIN | 3 | F |
| STL | 5 | MIL | 3 | F |
| ATL | 1 | PHI | 2 | F |
| ARI | 3 | WAS | 9 | F |
| CHC | 4 | PIT | 3 | F |
| SF | 4 | COL | 5 | F |
| SD | 3 | LAD | 8 | F |