Talk:Water main bursts in west Edinburgh; traffic, utilities disrupted

Latest comment: 13 years ago by Brian McNeil in topic Alarmist, inaccurate, poorly researched

OR

edit

Will go try get picks in about an hour... --Brian McNeil / talk 11:58, 28 May 2011 (UTC)Reply

Review of revision 1237447 [Passed]

edit

Alarmist, inaccurate, poorly researched

edit

This is the first version of this article that was submitted for review.

I live in Edinburgh, this happened - literally - four bus stops along the road from me. What was originally submitted for review is, in my opinion, utterly unacceptable. A city with near half a million inhabitants was not evacuated; nor was a 30 square mile area flooded by a burst metre-or-so diameter pipe.

Such overstatement, hyperbole, and alarmist reporting is not acceptable. That is why I actually went to the scene, took photographs, and spoke to locals. I would hope people will learn from this - you're writing for Wikinews, not the Daily Fail, Sun, or some other gutter rag. --Brian McNeil / talk 12:21, 29 May 2011 (UTC)Reply

Return to "Water main bursts in west Edinburgh; traffic, utilities disrupted" page.